The New York Bakery Boys

Scott Rodriguez 3 months ago

Alex one of the NY Bakery Boy brothers himself greeted, waited on me AND cooked my Ham, Egg & Cheese on a Kaiser roll on a griddle right in front of me, the way God intended. As a New Yorker this entire family should be put up for Sainthood for bringing an authentic slice of home down to central Florida. The best thing about this place for me, besides the amazing quality of the baked goods and terrific customer service, is it’s got breakfast all day. I got my slammin’ breakfast sandwich at 5:00pm 😎⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ I’m sure every other sandwich is delicious, but I always get breakfast here, and I’m in heaven. I live in Clearwater on the Gulf, a 2 hour drive otherwise I’d be here every day! However, every time I come to Orlando for anything this is a required visit. You will not regret coming here to eat, I guarantee it and if you do seek help!

Dee Yette 3 months ago

This place reminds me of a bodega and italian deli in one. Their shelves are stocked with select Italian imports and overseas snacks, like rare Oreo flavors found typically in Asian stores. As a weekly patron, I can say the deli sandwiches never disappoint. If you're in the area, stop by and try a breakfast sandwich or grab a fresh cannoli on the go. Be careful when reading the reviews for this place - there are 2 different shops being reviewed. This place is in Celebration, FL

Brian & Nicole Love 3 months ago

After dinner in Celebration, we decided to take a stroll and browse a few shops while walking off our meal. What a charming little gem this place is! It has the feel of an old-fashioned five-and-dime store, filled with unique and eclectic items you don't see everywhere. They offer a great selection of bagels and croissants, and their deli sandwiches looked absolutely delicious. There's a small dining area inside along with a couple of outdoor tables if you'd like to sit and enjoy your food. We didn't eat here on this visit, but after seeing all the delicious options, it's definitely on our list for next time! The staff was friendly and welcoming, which made the experience even better. I absolutely loved this little store. If you're in the area, stop in and take a look around - you never know what treasures you might discover!

Javier Hernandez 4 months ago

Walked in thinking this was still Market Street Deli. Turns out it’s now The New York Bakery Boys! Felt just like a bodega. Food was delicious and service was great. Perfect way to celebrate the Knicks advancing to the Finals. 10/10 🤌

Alex Henricks 5 months ago

The New York Bakery Boys lives up to their name and can't be accused of false advertising. This cool, little shop feels like it was taken right out of New York and transplanted to Florida. They have a great selection of bagels and a small deli as well incase you need more than bagels. The service was great. Our cashier knew the menu very well and made a couple of recommendations. I tried the french toast bagel and it definitely had the taste of french toast. We had to get some of the brightly colored plain bagels for the kids and they were a big hit. Probably the favorite item I bought from this place was the black and white cookie. It was delicious! They had lots of other baked treats as well to satisfy your sweet tooth. There is plenty of seating inside if you'd like to stay but we grabbed ours to go. We spent around $60 for two dozen bagels and four tubs of cream cheese. There is plenty of parking in the area. We'll visit again the next time we're in the neighborhood.